Collagen-induced arthritis, an animal model of rheumatoid arthritis, is associated with H-2 polymorphism, with H-2q being susceptible while H-2b being the resistant strain. We determined if CIA susceptibility is related to the presence of autoreactive T cells. A determination was made of the allo- and auto-reactivity of T cells in mice using synthetic peptides spanning residues 1-30, 30-60, and 60-90 of the Aαq and Aβq molecules. Varying degrees of alloresponses were measured using five strains of mice. B10 mice were the least responsive to the peptides while B10.M mice responded to five of the peptides. In terms of autoreactivity, neither B10.Q nor DBA/1 mice elicited measurable responses to the Aαq peptides. In contrast, DBA/1 but not B10.Q mice exhibited vigorous T cell responses following challenge using Aβq peptides. The addition of Aβq 30-60 but not Aαq 30-60 peptide augmented
Krco CJ, Harders J, Luthra H, et al. Arthritis Prone DBA/1 Mice Harbor Self MHC Class II-Reactive T cells. J Immunol Immunotech. 2014;1(1):1-9.
Collagen-induced arthritis is an animal model for rheumatoid arthritis with unknown etiology. A strong genetic predisposition is implicated in CIA as certain strains of mice develop CIA which is dependent on the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) class II polymorphism. H2-Aq and H-2Ar are associated with CIA susceptibility while H2-Ab, H2-Ad and H2-Af are associated with resistance to develop arthritis1 . CIA is a T cell dependent disease. MHC molecules are involved in positive and negative selection of T cells in thymus and also play a central role in regulation of immune responses. Antigen-specific T cell response requires 2 signals. The first is via the molecules that bind and present diverse peptides and second is through the co-stimulatory molecules present on the antigen presenting cells. The major function of MHC molecules is to generate response to pathogens and foreign antigens while maintaining self-tolerance in the immune system. Many mechanisms have been reported for generating self-tolerance including clonal deletion and anergy 2–4 . It has been reported that self MHC-derived peptides can be presented by class II molecules5 . We have shown presentation of Eβ-derived peptides by the H2-Aq molecule6 . Elution studies of naturally processed proteins from MHC class II molecules show presence of self-MHC derived peptides suggest that these peptides may be involved in tolerance or autoimmune responses .7,8 Similarly, allogeneic Aαk 60-90 peptide and autologous Aαd 60-70 peptide can bind to H-2Ad molecules. H2-Ab class II molecules can bind a peptide derived from the conserved Eα-chain with high affinity and compete for antigen presentation9 . Similarly, I-Ag7-derived peptides have been shown to bind to syngeneic and allogeneic peptides and modulate diabetes in NOD mice by eliciting T cell responses10 . The binding of self MHC peptides to autologous molecules is stable as evidenced by the observations that monoclonal antibodies can be raised against self Eα:Aβ complexes and that T cells can be induced to proliferate against self as well as allogeneic MHCclass II complexes. We have reported that allogeneic Eαk peptides are immunogenic and elicit measurable T cell responses in H-2E mice11 . We and others have reported that different class II molecules can present isotypic class II peptides. In humans, HLA-DR peptides can be presented by HLA-DQ molecules and elicit T cell responses
Materials and Methods
DBA/1J (H2-Aq), B10.Q (H2-Aq), B10 (H2-Ab), B10.K (H2-Ak), B10.M (H2-Af), B10.D2 (H2-Ad) and B10.S (H2-As) inbred strains of mice were obtained from Jackson laboratories. Six to eight week old mice were bred and maintained in the Immunogenetics Mouse Colony at the Mayo Clinic. All mouse husbandry and research protocols were monitored and approved by an Institutional Animal Care Committee.
All peptides including those spanning residues 1-30, 30-60, and 60-90 of the α- and β- chains of the Aq molecule (Table 1) were synthesized and purified at the Peptide Core Facility of the Mayo Clinic.
Mice were immunized and the draining lymph node cells (LNCs) challenged in vitro according to previously described protocols.12 Briefly, mice were immunized with 100 μg of peptide emulsified using complete Freund’s adjuvant. Seven days post injection, the draining lumbar, caudal, inguinal, and popliteal lymph nodes were harvested and challenged with peptides in vitro for 48 hr. Eighteen hours before termination of experiment 3H-thymidine was added to the cultures. The T cell activation was assessed by determining the amount of 3H-thymidine incorporation. T cell responses following peptide challenge are expressed as Δcpm =(mean cpm of triplicate cultures containing peptide)-(mean cpm of triplicate cultures containing medium).
Mixed Lymphocyte reactions:
DBA/1 lymph node cells (105 ) were co-cultured either with medium or 1 x 106 irradiated (3300 rads) spleen cells as antigen presenting cells (APCs) from self or other strains in a volume of 200 µl. Forty µg of peptides (20 µl volume) were added to the wells. Control wells included just media with cells but without the peptides. 3H-thymidine was added after 48 hr of culture. Cells were harvested and the extent of 3H-thymidine incorporation determined after 72 hr of in vitro culture. The graph depicts Δcpm (mean cpm of the cultures with cells and peptides- mean cpm of culture with cells but no peptide).
All comparisons were done using Student’s t test. A P value of <.05 was considered significant.
Immunization using peptides elicits allo- but not auto- T cell responses:
We tested CIA susceptible DBA/1 and other inbred mice for response to 30mers peptides spanning residues 1-90 derived from Aαq. At this region the Aαq and Aαb differ for 8 aa, some of which are conservative changes. The sequences for the peptides are given in Table 1.
The results of in vitro T cell proliferation in DBA/1 and a series of inbred lines of mice with peptide Aαq 1-30 are summarized in Figure 1. H-2d (B10.D2) and H-2k (B10.K) mice responded (Δcpm 32528±2821 and 30976±1239 respectively) vigorously to a recall peptide challenge while H-2f (B10.M) and H-2s (B10.S) mice generated a moderate response. B10 H-2b (B10) and H-2q (B10.Q and DBA/1) mice were unresponsive following immunization with self Aαq 1-30 peptide.
A comparison of T cell response to peptide Aαq 30-60 among various strains showed strongest response by B10.M mice (Δcpm 46233±4498) with moderate response by B10.S mice (Δcpm 23365±2440). All other strains of mice including H-2q mice were hypo-responsive. Similar to Aαq30-60 peptide, with the exception of B10.M and B10.S mice, all other mice did not respond (Δcpm<9,500) following Aαq 60-90 peptide. Among H-2q mice, DBA/1 mice exhibited a stronger propensity towards autoreactivity (Δcpm of 9,633±786) than did B10.Q mice (Δcpm of 875±123).
Overall, B10.M and B10.S showed much stronger responses to peptides derived from Aα 1-90 while DBA/1 and B10.Q, CIA susceptible strains, showed lower responses with statistically significant differences.
Immunization using Aβq peptides elicits both auto-as well as allo- T cell responses:
In contrast to the results obtained using Aαq peptides, much stronger and broader reactivity were measured following immunizations using Aβq peptides. Strong T cell proliferative responses were measured following Aβq1-30 peptide challenge (Δcpm’s 23,000-33,000) in H-2d,f,k mice (Figure 2). Both H-2b and H-2s mice were unresponsive (cpm’s<5,500). Interestingly, DBA/1 (Δcpm 33,434±3271) generated a much stronger response compared to B10.Q (Δcpm 2336±218) suggesting presence of autoreactive T cells to the self Aβq 1-30 peptide. Nearly all of the tested mouse strains responded to varying degrees following immunization using Aβq 30-60 peptide, although H-2 b,k,s inbred lines of mice were less responsive.
In H-2Aq mice, B10.Q mice did not respond (Δcpm 5,488) to an in vitro challenge with self peptide Aβq 30-60,while DBA/1 mice responded very vigorously (Δcpm52,571±6307). Mice expressing H-2b,f haplotypes exhibited similar T cell responses following in vitro challenge using peptide Aβq 60-90 (Δcpm’s 23,000-30,000). However, neither B10.Q nor DBA/1 mice were autoreactive to Aβq 60-90 peptide.
Overall these data showed strong T cell response generated by DBA/1 mice to self-derived peptides 30-60 and 60-90, both were non-responsive in B10.Q mice. All differences were statistically significant between the B10 and B10.Q and DBA/1 mice.
Draining lymph node cells from primed mice were challenged in vitro with peptides and T cell responses measured. Medium control values varied between 1,000 and 5,000 cpm. * p<0.01 DBA/1 compared with other strains.
Draining lymph node cells from primed mice were challenged in vitro with peptides and T cell responses measured. Medium control values varied between 1,000 and 5,000 cpm. *p<0.01 DBA/1 compared with other strains.tides and T cell responses measured. Medium control values varied between 1,000 and 5,000 cpm. * p<0.01 DBA/1 compared with other strains.
Aβq 30-60 peptide augments allo- and auto-reactivity of DBA/1 lymph node cells:
In light of the strong autoreactivity of peptide Aβq 30-60 in DBA/1 mice, a series of experiments were performed ascertaining the in vitro effects of adding self peptide to cultures of LNCs fromDBA/1 (Figure 03). The addition of immunogenic self Aβq 30-60 but not Aαq 30-60 peptide induced some activation of LNCs of naïve DBA/1 mice (cpm 1,977). Only after specific immunization could responses for Aβq 30-60 be detected. We then performed MLR using DBA/1 splenic cells as stimulators. The addition of Aβq 30-60 but not Aαq 30-60 peptide (cpms of 37,945 and 9,386 respectively) augmented an autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (cpm 9,791) in DBA/1 mice. The immunopotentiating effect of Aβq 30-60 peptide was also observed when DBA/1 T cells were stimulated with allogeneic MLR assays where spleen cells from B10.D2 or B10 mice were used. The responses of DBA/1 cells to B10 or B10.D2 stimulator cells was augmented if Aβq 30-60 peptide was added during in vitro culture initiation. The addition of Aαq 30-60 peptide to cultures containing allogeneic B10 or B10.D2 was without effect.
DBA/1 lymph node cells were cocultured either with medium or 1 x 106 irradiated (3300 rads) spleen cells, from self or other strains, and peptides and T cell proliferation measured.
Priming with human collagen peptide 250-270 confers reactivity to peptide Aβq 30-60:
DBA/1 mice develop chronic inflammatory arthritis following immunization using heterologous type II collagen. We and others have reported that one of the determinants recognized by DBA/1 T cells on human type II collagen is located within residues 250-270.14 We therefore determined the effects of adding either Aαq 30-60 or Aβq 30-60 peptide to cultures of DBA/1 T cells primed to human type II collagen (HII) peptide 250-270 (Figure 4). Under conditions in which DBA/1 cells responded to challenge using HII peptide 250-270 (Δcpm 29163), the addition of peptide Aβq 30-60 but not Aαq 30-60 increased the response to the collagen peptide. Interestingly, HII 250-270 peptide primed cells responded if challenged with Aβq 30-60 but not Aαq 30-60 peptides.
Mice were primed with HII 250-270 peptide and draining lymph node cells were cultured in the presence of the immunizing peptide and self-derived peptides Aαq 30-60 and Aβq 30-60 separately or in combination and T cell responses was measured.
The studies reported here support previous observations that self-MHC derived peptides may be involved in tolerance or pathogenicity. 15,16 Our observations reveal that all self-MHC peptides elicited different patterns of allogeneic T cell responses among the inbred strains of mice tested. Some of the Aβq peptides elicited vigorous self reactivity in DBA/1 but not B10.Q mice. In addition, Aβq 30-60 peptide augmented self- and non-self responses of DBA/1 T cells. Both B10.Q and DBA/1 mice are susceptible to CIA and carry same class II allele. This data supports role of genetic factors other than the class II genes may also be involved in overall immune response. CIA-resistant B10.M (H-2f) mice exhibited the strongest propensity to respond, responding to five of the six peptides, while B10 (H-2b) mice were characterized by the weakest peptide responses. T regulatory cells have been shown to be selected on self-peptides.17 One can speculate that CIA-resistant mice harbor self-reactive T regulatory cells. Collectively, these findings suggest that self MHC peptide ligands may have potent influences on immune responses.
It was not possible to directly correlate the number of disparate residues with T cell reactivity. For example, H-2Ab and H-2Aq molecules differ at three residues corresponding to peptide Aαq 1-30 yet B10 mice do not respond. In contrast, H-2Ad and H-2Aq molecules differ at only two residues yet B10.D2 mice respond as well as B10.M mice which differ at three residues. Complex factors, including affinity and avidity of the peptides, in addition to sequence disparity probably contribute towards determining the magnitude of T cell responses to class II peptides.
An insight into the complexity of the peptide responses is further evidenced by the differing auto-responsiveness between DBA/1 and B10.Q mice. B10.Q mice were uniformly unresponsive to all six of the Aαq and Aβq peptides. In contrast, while DBA/1 mice responded to most of the Aβq peptides, they did not respond to any of the Aαq peptides. It has been reported that synthetic self Aαk 1-16 and Aβk 1-18 peptides elicit T cell responses in B10.A mice. 15 However, not all syngeneic class II peptides are immunogenic. We have reported that H-2E+ mice do not respond in vitro to synthetic Eαk peptides collectively spanning residues 90-150.11
The immunopotentiating effects of peptide Aβq 30-60 bears comment. We measured increase in LNCs responses from DBA/1 mice to allo- (B10.D2, B10) and auto- (DBA/1) challenge in vitro using irradiated spleen cells following the addition of Aβq 30-60 peptide. In contrast, the addition of Aαq 30-60 peptide was without effect. A study using rats with CIA showed that immunization with type II collagen lead to activation of autoreactive T cells which responded in autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction possibly due to T cell reactivity to self-MHC peptides.18 Similarly, some HLA-DR peptides can alter HLA-DR restricted allorecognition in vitro and in vivo. 19 Naturally processed class II peptides can be detected in the binding pockets of mouse and human class II molecules.20 These observations have led to theoretical concepts by us as well as by others that the physical binding of class II peptides to MHC molecules has functional consequences in autoimmunity.12 Human HLA-DR and DQ genes are homologous to mouse H2-E and H2-A genes. Patients with RA harbor type II collagen-related antibodies and reactive T and B cells 21,23 suggesting CIA in mice can serve to determine pathogenesis of RA.23
It has been hypothesized that some motifs of the third hypervariable region of HLA-DRB1 molecule play a role in the development of rheumatoid arthritis. Using human class II transgenic mice, we have been able to demonstrate a direct correlation between T cell responses to human class II peptides and resistance/susceptibility to reactive arthritis. 12,23 Our observation that the responses to human collagen peptide 250-270 is potentiated by the addition of Aβq30-60 peptide provides additional support for the role of class II peptides in modulating disease states. H-2A polymorphism has been associated with modulation of CIA via self MHC class II peptides.24 These observations are reminiscent of that observed in non-obese diabetes (NOD) mice where some H-2Ag7 peptides may alter progression in diabetes.10
The mechanism which confers autoreactivity to some Aβq peptides in DBA/1 mice is not known. A direct link between theT cells reactive to self-peptides is suggested by a tendency of DBA/1 mice primed to Aβq but not Aβq 30-60 peptide to have higher medium control values (not shown). However, since most autoimmune diseases are multigenic, an indirect role of the self-derived peptides is much more likely. It is possible that these self-derived MHC peptides are involved in positive selection of T cells in the thymus and the T cell repertoire selected by these peptides may have a different Th profile. In CIA susceptible mice, self-peptide reactive T cells may be producing pro-inflammatory cytokines, which under normal conditions may not be pathogenic. One can envisage that in genetically susceptible subjects harboring T cells reactive to self-class II molecules that infections or possibly superantigens, may cause proliferation of the self-reactive T cells contributing to inflammation and arthritis. These events need to be evaluated in future studies.
- Nabozny GH, David CS. The immunogenetic basis of collagen induced arthritis in mice: an experimental model for the rational design of immunomodulatory treatments of rheumatoid arthritis. Adv Exp Med Biol. 1994;347: 55-63.
- Kappler JW, Roehm N, Marrack P. T cell tolerance by clonal elimination in the thymus. Cell. 1987;49(2):273-280.
- Kappler JW, Staerz U, White J, Marrack PC. Self-tolerance eliminates T cells specific for Mls-modified products of the major histocompatibility complex. Nature. 1988;332(6159):35-40.
- Roberts JL, Sharrow SO, Singer A. Clonal deletion and clonal anergy in the thymus induced by cellular elements with different radiation sensitivities. J Exp Med. 1990; 171(3):935-940.
- Fedoseyeva EV, Tam RC, Orr PL, et al. Presentation of a self-peptide for in vivo tolerance induction of CD4+ T cells is governed by a processing factor that maps to the class II region of the major histocompatibility complex locus. J Exp Med. 1995;182(5):1481-1491.
- Gonzalez-Gay MA, Zanelli E, Krco CJ, et al. Polymorphism of the MHC class II Eb gene determines the protection against collagen-induced arthritis. Immunogenetics. 1995; 42(1):35-40.
- Rudensky A, Preston-Hurlburt P, Hong SC, et al. Sequence analysis of peptides bound to MHC class II molecules. Nature. 1991;353(6345):622-627.
- Lorenz RG, Allen PM. Direct evidence for functional self-protein/Ia-molecule complexes in vivo. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1988;85:5220-5223.
- Brown NK, McCormick DJ, David CS, et al. H2E-derived Ealpha52-68 peptide presented by H2Ab interferes with clonal deletion of autoreactive T cells in autoimmune thyroiditis. J Immunol. 2008;180(10):7039-7046.
- Chaturvedi P, Agrawal B, Zechel M, et al. A self MHC class II beta-chain peptide prevents diabetes in nonobese diabetic mice. J Immunol. 2000;164(12):6610-6620.
- Krco CJ, Beito TG, David CS. Determination of tolerance to self E alpha peptides by clonal elimination of H-2E reactive T cells and antigen presentation by H-2A molecules. Transplantation. 1992;54(5):920-923.
- Zanelli EC, Krco CJ, Baisch JM, et al. Immune response of HLA-DQ8 transgenic mice to peptides from the third hypervariable region of HLA-DRB1 correlates with predisposition to rheumatoid arthritis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1996;93(5):1814-1819.
- Braem K, Carter S, Lories RJ. Spontaneous arthritis and ankylosis in male DBA/1 mice: further evidence for a role of behavioral factors in "stress-induced arthritis". Biol Proced Online. 2012;14(1):10.
- Krco CJ, Pawelski J, Harders J, et al. Characterization of the antigenic structure of human type II collagen. J Immunol. 1996;156(8):2761-2768.
- Benichou G, Takizawa PA, Ho PT, et al. Immunogenicity and tolerogenicity of self-major histocompatibility complex peptides. J Exp Med. 1990;172(5):1341-1346.
- Bayrak S, Holmdahl R, Travers P, et al. T cell response of I-Aq mice to self type II collagen: meshing of the binding motif of the I-Aq molecule with repetitive sequences results in autoreactivity to multiple epitopes. Int Immunol. 1997;9(11):1687-1699.
- Kronenberg M, Rudensky A. Regulation of immunity by self-reactive T cells. Nature. 2005;435(7042):598-604.
- Catchpole B, Ward FJ, Hamblin AS, et al. Autoreactivity in collagen-induced arthritis of rats: a potential role for T cell responses to self MHC peptides. Journal of autoimmunity. 2002;18(4):271-280.
- Murphy B, Magee CC, Alexander SI, et al. Inhibition of allorecognition by a human class II MHC-derived peptide through the induction of apoptosis. J Clin Invest. 1999;103(6):859-867.
- Chicz RM, Urban RG, Gorga JC, et al. Specificity and promiscuity among naturally processed peptides bound to HLA-DR alleles. J Exp Med. 1993;178(1):27-47.
- He X, Kang AH, Stuart JM. Accumulation of T cells reactive to type II collagen in synovial fluid of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. The Journal of rheumatology. 2000;27(3):589-593.
- Luckey D, Medina K, Taneja V. B cells as effectors and regulators of sex-biased arthritis. Autoimmunity.2012;45(5):364-76.
- Taneja V, David CS. Role of HLA class II genes in susceptibility/resistance to inflammatory arthritis: studies with humanized mice. Immunol Rev. 2010;233(1):62-78.
- Gonzalez-Gay MA, Zanelli E, Khare SD. H2-A polymorphism contributes to H2-Ebeta-mediated protection in collagen-induced arthritis. Immunogenetics. 1996;44(5):377-384.